Sienna SpencerChief Marketing Officer · Essays & perspective

Pipeline reporting5 min read

Earning the confidence of a payroll customer

Software boards routinely ask marketing how much pipeline it sourced. The figure is easy to inflate, hard to audit and says little about whether customers will arrive, pay and stay. I stopped reporting it in 2021.

Most board packs in business-to-business software contain a slide I used to enjoy presenting. It shows the value of the sales pipeline that marketing sourced in the quarter, usually as a rising bar with a dotted goal line beneath it. The number is large, it moves in the right direction and it gives directors something concrete to ask about. I stopped presenting it at Yarrowby in 2021, and I now think most software boards would be better informed without it.

Continue the essay

The enduring idea

Marketing in payroll software has done its job only when the customer it found is still paying its people through us two years later.

A philosophy in practice ↗

The journal

Further reading.

  1. 02

    Trust after an incident5 min read

    After a breach, stop advertising your security

    When a software company suffers a security incident, marketing is usually asked for a campaign that reassures the market. I think the better answer is a year without security advertising and a steady supply of evidence customers can check for themselves.

  2. 03

    Self-service and onboarding5 min read

    Product-led growth ends at the first pay run

    Free tiers and self-service trials can bring payroll customers to the door. They cannot safely carry them through the first live pay run, and a product-led model that pretends otherwise moves its costs into customers' payslips.

Revenue, year to 30 June 2026
A$198m
Australia A$148m, United Kingdom A$31m, New Zealand A$19m
Employees paid through Yarrowby
1.05m
Across about 7,400 employers with 50 to 2,000 staff
Gross revenue retention, FY2026
95.4%
Recovered from 92.6% in the year after the May 2023 incident

A payroll customer hands us every employee's pay and bank details, so I judge marketing by the customers who stay, not the leads we count.

I am the chief marketing officer of Yarrowby Software Limited, a fictional ASX-listed company whose cloud software pays 1.05 million people across Australia, New Zealand and the United Kingdom. Our customers are about 7,400 mid-market employers, from aged-care operators and regional manufacturers to hospitality groups and engineering firms, most with between 50 and 2,000 staff. Revenue for the year to June 2026 was A$198 million, three-quarters of it earned in Australia. I lead 64 people across demand generation, product marketing, partner marketing, brand and customer communications.

Payroll is an unusual thing to market. Nobody wants to change it, everyone notices when it fails, and the person who signs the contract is rarely the person who runs the pay each fortnight. I learnt to sell into that kind of reluctance slowly: writing direct mail for a copier dealer in Newcastle, running accounts at a Sydney business-to-business agency, spending vendor funds at a Brisbane software reseller, building the first honest pipeline report at a Melbourne managed-services provider, and working with thousands of accounting practices for a cloud accounting company in London. I came home to join Yarrowby in March 2021.

The defining weeks of my time here came in May 2023, when attackers used passwords stolen from other websites to get into our employee app and redirect nine people's pay. We repaid those employees within two days, wrote to every customer rather than only the 58 affected, and stopped all advertising for eight weeks. I apply the lesson to every marketing decision I make. A payroll company's promise is kept by its systems and its people; marketing's task is to describe that promise precisely and never to run ahead of the evidence for it.

A pipeline report that sales and finance both accept

We retired lead quotas in 2021 and agreed one written definition of a qualified opportunity with sales. Reported pipeline fell from A$61 million to A$37 million on paper. Win rates on qualified opportunities then rose from 19 to 27 per cent, and the months needed to recover acquisition cost fell from 31 to 22.

Retention rebuilt after a security incident

Gross revenue retention dropped from 95.1 per cent to 92.6 per cent in the year after the May 2023 incident. By June 2026 it stood at 95.4 per cent, with multi-factor sign-in compulsory on every employee account and no security advertising at all for the first twelve months.

Partners paid for customers who stay

Replacing one-off referral fees with a three-year revenue share cost us 190 referring partners in its first year. Partner-referred customers still with us after eighteen months rose from 62 to 89 per cent, and partners now introduce 34 per cent of our new recurring revenue.

A price change explained bill by bill

Our 2025 move to per-employee bundles raised the average bill by 8.5 per cent. With 120 days' notice, a 15 per cent first-year cap and a letter showing each customer their own old and new bill, price-related cancellations came to 1.4 per cent of recurring revenue against the 3.5 per cent we had modelled.

Current focus

I am working with our product and finance leaders on the next stage of our self-service journey: deciding which setup steps customers can safely complete alone and where an implementation specialist must stay involved before a first live pay run. I am also preparing the board's annual review of marketing spend, which this year asks whether our brand investment in the United Kingdom has earned the shortlist gains it earned at home.

Conversations I welcome

I intend to stay at Yarrowby while our UK plan and the redesign of our self-service journey are under way. I would consider one non-executive directorship at an ASX-listed or member-owned organisation outside software, where customer trust and digital channels are board questions, taken with my own board's consent. I can give about 25 days a year. I also accept a small number of invitations to speak to marketing, product and governance audiences.

Beyond the page

The record behind the perspective.

In the boardroom

  • Merrigal Learning FoundationNon-executive director, unpaid · 2021–present

Formation

  • Bachelor of Commerce (Marketing)Hunterdale University · 1999
  • Graduate Certificate in Marketing Analytics, part-timeHunterdale University · 2011
On the first evening of the incident Sienna brought me two drafts: the letter our lawyers preferred and the one she thought customers deserved. She was clear which she favoured and why, and equally clear that the decision was mine. That is how an executive should work with a chief executive, and it is rarer than it ought to be.
Alasdair PennickFictional chief executive, Yarrowby Software Limited
The full record ↗

Contact

I intend to stay at Yarrowby while our UK plan and the redesign of our self-service journey are under way. I would consider one non-executive directorship at an ASX-listed or member-owned organisation outside software, where customer trust and digital channels are board questions, taken with my own board's consent. I can give about 25 days a year. I also accept a small number of invitations to speak to marketing, product and governance audiences.

  • Board appointments
  • Speaking invitations