I test the commercial work behind a music retailer’s growth choices: the service behind an instrument sale, the obligations behind a resale offer and the utilisation behind a rental fleet.
I began commercial analysis with a preference for a clean comparison. Two alternatives were easier to discuss when they could be placed in adjacent columns. Over time I learned that the most consequential difference often sat outside the first table:work one option required, specialist capacity another assumed, or a responsibility that remained after ownership changed. Strategy became more useful to me when it made those differences discussable rather than removing them to produce a simpler recommendation.
A new format changes the work the retailer must carry, not only the way it receives money. I want that work visible before a promising revenue line becomes an expansion commitment.